• If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • Whenever you search in PBworks or on the Web, Dokkio Sidebar (from the makers of PBworks) will run the same search in your Drive, Dropbox, OneDrive, Gmail, Slack, and browsed web pages. Now you can find what you're looking for wherever it lives. Try Dokkio Sidebar for free.


March 3, 2010 OpenID Meetup Minutes

Page history last edited by Chris Messina 13 years ago

Recorded by Monica Keller.

  1. Built agenda :)
  2. Worked on agenda/mingled


  • David Recordon
  • Randy Farmer
  • Monica Keller
  • Joseph Smarr
  • Dick Hardt
  • Chris Messina
  • Kevin Marks
  • Beau Lebens
  • Luke Shepard
  • Allen Tom
  • Dustin Whittle
  • Greg Cohen
  • Rohit Khare
  • Missed a few more people sorry

Event Link



  1. Agenda for the Open ID Summit
  2. Combining OpenID and OAuth 
  3. Name for OpenID – OpenID vNext vs Open ID 3.0

1. OpenID Summit Agenda - April 6th in Mountain View

  • Dick Hardt is hoping to introduce to the broader team at the summit the fact that a new version of the spec is being developed
    • Current plan is to call it: OpenID v Next but there is still debate on the name
  • Monica Keller proposed to present a list of "stellar implementations" on the current version first
  • David Recordon and Joseph Smarr: Acknowledged requirements have changed over the last two years and should be gathered once again
  • Randy Farmer would like to present: Why I can’t advise my clients to use OpenID ?
    • Talk about all the issues with OpenID today
      • Why aren’t you using OpenID Twitter ?
      • Why is FB Connect "easier"
    • Collect requirements
    • Find volunteers who will lead a working group to investigate solutions
  • Joseph recommended using : Google Moderator during the summit and maybe use it a week before to gather some good requirements
  • Other topics to discuss at Summit
    • Logout vs revocation; do users understand ? 

2. OpenID  + OAuth

Proposal by Joseph Smarr 

  • No discovery but use well known urls 
  • How does Connect work ? 
  • Hard for RPs to do discovery

Group discussion should we use WebFinger instead of Attribute Exchange ?

  • Problems with WebFinger: Too many roundrips
  • Smarr>> discovery based on xml
  • Action Item: Smarr will host web finger meetup next week
  • Dick add your input here. You were talking about trusting DNS to verify email addresses port 80 and port 25 -- didn't follow the issue well enough
  • Dick proposed that we even use attribute exchange to provide the list of services because the list of services you use may be considered private data
    • Monica and Beau: Don't think that is a very common case 
  • Luke and Dave: Just use OAuth  

3. Naming of Open ID v Next

  • Erich Sachs prefers Open ID 3.0

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.